Some films are appreciated from the start — the big blockbusters find their audiences or the acclaimed indies find the critical raves right out of the gate.
Then there are films that are ahead of their time, that find a bigger audience as they age, where the appreciation might come a little later thanks to DVDs or television viewings.
When A Knight’s Tale opened in theatres on May 11, 2001, it wasn’t without fanfare.
It made its money back, had its fans and was notable for its fresh-faced cast who would go on to prominent careers.
But it wasn’t a runaway hit; some were confused by the anachronisms and simply couldn’t get past a film about jousting that opens to the strains of Queen‘s ‘We Will Rock You.’
The film also had the misfortune to be praised by a non-existent critic — a major misstep by the studio’s marketing department.
The original Bridgerton
While Helgeland has not seen that show, he recently read a review.
“They were praising having modern dances in this older setting and I was just like, ‘What?'” he recalls with a laugh, before adding the piece did go on to mention his film.
Its impact is visible in more personal ways: people with tattoos of famous lines from the film, individuals who request the costumes for their weddings, journalists who tell everyone involved with the film that it’s their favorite of all time. (Ahem.)
Helgeland says it caught him off guard at first.
“I guess because it’s a strange movie,” he says. “You know, there’s actually a whole group of medievalists who have PhDs and stuff and have written footnoted, scholarly discussions about it.”
For the uninitiated, A Knight’s Tale focuses on William Thatcher, a 14th-century peasant who believes one can “change their stars” — he longs to compete as a knight but is forbidden because he’s not of noble birth.
When his master, Sir Ector, dies, he takes his place and begins competing illegally in tournaments under the name Ulrich von Liechtenstein.
He is aided by his fellow squires, the reasonable Roland (Mark Addy), the temperamental Wat (Alan Tudyk) and a hype man who happens to be none other than Geoffrey Chaucer (Paul Bettany).
They are later joined by female blacksmith Kate (Laura Fraser), so ahead of her time her logo bears a striking resemblance to the Nike swoosh.
There’s also a feminist love interest in the form of Jocelyn (Shannyn Sossamon) a lady of noble birth, who’s lady-in-waiting is played by future Oscar nominee Bérénice Bejo.
And no such film would be complete without a delightfully hiss-able villain, here in the form of Count Adhemar (Rufus Sewell), who also competes for Jocelyn’s affections.
More than ‘oddball nonfiction’
The story delves into destiny, friendship and the quality of mercy but does so with unique action sequences, poetry, music, intelligence and above all, a sense of fun and joy that, as Helgeland goes on to explain, was a reflection of the shooting process.
Helgeland spoke about the journey A Knight’s Tale took to the big screen, including Heath Ledger’s didgeridoo, Daniel Craig‘s audition and his utter determination to cast newcomer Paul Bettany.
After starting with scripting horror films like A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master and 976-EVIL, Helgeland had become an in-demand screenwriter.
He was fresh off an Academy Award (with director Curtis Hanson) for adapting 1997’s L.A. Confidential.
That same year he was credited on the Mel Gibson/Julia Roberts hit Conspiracy Theory and the Kevin Costner not-a-hit The Postman. (Helgeland has the rare distinction of having won an Academy Award and a Razzie in the same year).
He made his directorial debut with 1999’s Payback, starring Gibson. After filming that, he remembered an “oddball nonfiction” book he had read called Tournament.
“It was a nice read, because it was mostly pictures. It was about how jousting was a sport, a competition, back then. One of the things that stuck with me was that you had to be of noble birth to compete.
“Even though I’d read it previously, it suddenly sparked an idea in me: He’s a peasant. It resonated because I was trying to go from being a screenwriter to a director and I thought, ‘Directors are nobles and screenwriters are peasants!’ So he’s a screenwriter who wants to be a director. And Mark Addy is the DP and Alan Tudyk is the production designer, and so on and so forth,” Helgeland said.
Though a film about jousting with modern music might seem like a tough sell at the time … it was not.
“I wrote it on spec, sent it out everywhere. For whatever reason, it got a great reaction, a bunch of places wanting to meet, all within 48 hours. I sold it to Sony right away. They didn’t give me notes, they just said, ‘We want to make this movie now. We want you to start meeting actors.'”
Casting Heath Ledger
Heath Ledger had just broken through in 10 Things I Hate About You and was filming The Patriot for Sony at the time, and executives were excited by the dailies.
Ledger had two weeks off and was flying from North Carolina to Australia, with a five-hour layover in Los Angeles.
Helgeland went to meet him at the space age structure at LAX that was, at the time, a restaurant called Encounters (it closed in 2013).
“He came off this long flight and he had a tube with him, like something an architect would keep his drawings in.
“We sat down for lunch and hit it off right away. He loved the script. He was like, ‘I get to ride a horse, I get to joust, I get to sword-fight I get to have a romance, I get to be insane. I get to dance!’ So we really didn’t talk too much about it, just got to know each other.
“I finally said, ‘What’s in the tube?’ He said, ‘Oh, that’s my didgeridoo.’ And he pulls it out, and he’s showing it to me and telling me what it is.
“And then I said, ‘Can you play it? Or do you just kind of carry it around?’ And the next thing I know, he’s playing it in the restaurant. And he’s amazing and I’m thinking, ‘Who’s going to come in and do better than this?'”
Helgeland says he only seriously met with one other actor — Paul Walker, who would break out with The Fast and the Furious in 2001, the same year A Knight’s Tale was released.
“I really liked him a lot. Of his age group, he was the star. But he was so American, I wasn’t sure he’d get the Englishness of it,” Helgeland said.
After casting Ledger, Sony hoped to surround him with star names in the supporting roles, resulting in some unique casting suggestions.
“Mark Addy was right off The Full Monty, he was easily the most well-known member of the cast. Sony was happy to have him. But they wanted Hugh Grant for Chaucer. I just didn’t see him doing it, he’s was starring in big movies, he wasn’t going to play second fiddle.
“And then they wanted Drew Carey for Chaucer. Nothing against Drew Carey but I was like, ‘How are we going to have Drew Carey walking around in this movie?’ I rejected him for Chaucer, then they wanted him for Wat. But Alan had done an off-Broadway show and an executive was high on him for Wat. I think Alan came in and read, and it was over. It was undeniable.
“The two hardest parts to cast were Chaucer and Jocelyn. [Casting director] Francine Maisler had found Shannyn, she was a DJ at Gwyneth Paltrow‘s birthday party.
“Francine asked her if she’d ever acted and had her come in and read on a couple different projects to get her some experience. Nothing had really clicked, I think Knight’s Tale was the first thing she was ever in outside some MTV videos.”
The fight for Paul Bettany
From the start, Helgeland was committed to casting Paul Bettany as Chaucer; he met the actor he met while working on a previous film.
Bettany makes a memorable Hollywood debut in the film, appearing stark naked.
“I had tried to do a movie at Fox before A Knight’s Tale and while we were casting, Paul had come in to read for some other movies. An actor left the sides to my film on the table and he said, ‘I don’t want to meet on this other movie, I want to be on this movie.’
“I had gone to lunch and he had a flight to catch, so they put him on tape. When I saw it, I was like, ‘Where is he? This is the guy!’ And he was already on his way to London. I was convinced he was the guy but he hadn’t done anything you could show anybody and Fox was like, We’re not casting this guy.’
“They wanted me to meet Joaquin Phoenix for another role and he was in London so I said, ‘I’ll go to meet him only if I can screen test Paul Bettany.’
“So I pulled out every favour I had and got a location, another actor to read with him, and cut it all together and they still wouldn’t do it. And that movie fell apart. But while I was in London, we went drinking every night and became buddies.
“So I wrote Chaucer for Paul and sent him the script. And day or two went by and he called on the phone and it was basically like, ‘You f–k, you f–ker!’ And it was Paul.
“He goes, ‘I’m naked! I’m f–king naked.’ And I said, ‘Do you want to do it or don’t you?’ And he goes, ‘Of course I want to do it!’ And I go, ‘Okay, because it’s gonna be a struggle.'”
By now, Bettany had some buzz on him thanks to appearing in the brutal British crime drama Gangster No. 1, but his role in that was very different.
“Sony executives saw that film and were like, ‘You want this guy to play Chaucer? He’s a psychopath!’ So Paul came and stayed with me and we shot like 100 different versions of scenes and they just kept saying, ‘No, no, no. He’s not funny enough. Chaucer is so funny in the script and this guy is not funny. What’s wrong with you?’
“It was almost like they were worried about my mental health. There’s a scene when you first meet him and he steps on a thorn and pulls it out of his foot. I said, ‘Paul, put your foot in your mouth and pull it out.’ And we shot it that way, he sort of contorts himself. And I showed it to them and they all started laughing and that’s what won them over.”
Helgeland also had a couple close brushes with James Bond in his casting.
“I cast James Purefoy as Edward, the Black Prince, and I was like, ‘This guy is going to be James Bond.’ When he’d walk on the set, we’d all start singing the theme to James Bond, the ‘dun-dun-dun-dun.’ And he’d say, ‘Oh, stop!’
“Actually, Daniel Craig came in to read for Count Adhemar and he was fantastic. This was long before he was Bond, obviously. He was just amazing. But I had already taken to Rufus Sewell for the role. I came close to changing my mind but it ultimately came down to Daniel was blond and Heath was blond and I though the contrast in looks with Heath and Rufus was better. And they became best friends, those two, they would carouse through Prague together.”
Ahead of its time and historically accurate
Helgeland cast Scottish actor Laura Fraser as Kate, a widow who takes up her husband’s trade as a blacksmith.
Many have remarked on Fraser’s chemistry with Ledger, and thought they might end up together in the film.
“I take it as a compliment as far as the writing goes because people care about these characters. The sidekicks are all good enough characters that people are attached to them.
“The conceit in my head is that all these characters around William, with the exception of Chaucer, are broken-hearted. You only know it when they do the love letter. But they’re all broken-hearted except for Heath, who is in love. And they’re all in love with Heath in a way.
“It’s funny because some people complained about a woman being a blacksmith. And that would really make me mad because it was true.
“The blacksmiths had a guild at that time and one of the rules of the guild was if you were married to a blacksmith and he died, you could take up his trade to support the blacksmith’s kids.
“But they couldn’t make ornate stuff, they could only make practical things like horseshoes. So when you first see her, she’s carrying a rod with horseshoes on it. So there’s actually a lot of research in there.”
Behind-the-scenes cast secrets
Shooting took place Prague, primarily at Barrandov Studios. The main group — Ledger, Addy, Bettany, Tudyk, Sossyman and Berenice Bejo — even lived together.
“We were all in the Czech Republic and Communism had fallen not long ago. So it was pristine, not filled with tourists. It was a hip, cool place and we were all there for the long haul. They all became really close.
“Heath used to say that he loved the movie, because he thought it was a photo album of how much fun they had doing it. That charm between that group was because it was real, they really did love each other. For years afterwards, whenever they were in the same city someplace, they’d get together. Or I’d get a call from Heath out of the blue and he’d say, ‘Alan and Rufus are here, let’s go out to eat!’ Heath was always so happy when we were together.
“One time, like four years later, we were at dinner and I told Heath [that] Todd Black, the producer, was coming. Heath said, ‘When he gets here let’s all pick him up and run down the street with him!’ We were all like, ‘No, no.’ But Heath was determined.
“So Todd shows up and Heath goes to hug him but instead picks him up and runs down the street with him. That’s how much he loved the experience and these people.”
The film boasted an amazing soundtrack and incorporated songs like Queen’s ‘We Will Rock You’ and David Bowie’s ‘Golden Years.’ The one song Helgeland didn’t get to use was David Essex’s ‘Rock on.’
“We had a whole travelling sequence for that song, but I couldn’t get enough footage to make it work. Whenever we had time, we’d try to grab a shot of them walking down the road and it was going to show them going from one tournament to the next. We just didn’t have the footage for it.
“I fought to get a couple extra days so we could finish the montage. Actually, the fart scene that closes the movie was originally shot for that. When I couldn’t make the sequence work, I salvaged that for the end credits.”
One of the most famous lines was an improvisation. After William calls Jocelyn a silly girl, she responds: “Better a silly girl with a flower than a silly boy with a horse and a stick” and walks away.
Wat’s line in the script was: “It’s called a lance.” But Helgeland thought something was missing and asked Tudyk to play around with it.
“Everyone was there, it’s a wide shot, the whole cast is watching. And Alan throws out a couple jokes. And it didn’t work. We did another take and it wasn’t funny. And another. Now everyone is looking at him like, ‘You suck.’
“I was embarrassed for him and said we should move on but he was like, ‘No no no I’ll get it!’ We’re now on take seven, eight, nine. This is a three-take movie. It was the most shots we did for any scene in the film.
“He keeps trying and poor Alan is just dying. Suddenly, I see him get this look and I know to roll. And he says the line, ‘It’s called a lance,’ and adds: ‘Hello?’ And everyone laughed and we were hugging him. It was such a struggle, he had been so humiliated and he pulled it off.”
A Knight’s Tale was released on May 11, 2001, making US$16.5 million (approx. $21.2 million) in its opening weekend.
It went on to gross US$56.5 million (approx. $72.5 million) in the States and nearly US$61 million (approx. $78.2 million) internationally, for a respectable worldwide gross of over US$117 million (approx. $150 million).
A cult classic with relative Box Office success
“It made its money back but wasn’t a hit by any by any stretch,” Helgland said.
“It came out a week before Shrek, which was a monster hit. So we had one weekend and kind of got swallowed up by Shrek. It made a profit. You wish it made more, but I was so happy with the movie.
“I would much rather be happy with the movie and have it disappoint at the box office than have it be a hit and be disappointed with the film.”
Unfortunately, marketing had made up a quote for the film’s poster, creating a critic named David Manning, who also supplied quotes for other films, including The Animal.
Following an investigation by Newsweek journalist John Horn, it was soon revealed that Manning did not exist.
“I was so mad — they didn’t tell us they were going to do that,” Helgeland said. “And it was like, ow you’ve made it seem like the movie stinks. And you had to make up quotes for it.”
“It was kind of ugly, really. They didn’t have the exact quote they wanted, so they made it up. I found out about it reading about it; no one even had the decency to call and [say], ‘Hey, look, we did something and it’s going to be a problem.'”
A Knight’s Tale‘s legacy
Helgeland would go on to more success, penning scripts like Mystic River and Man on Fire and directing films like 42, which cast Chadwick Boseman in his first lead film role.
But A Knight’s Tale was ahead of its time and people began to catch up.
At one point, Helgeland realised the film was still resonating and being discovered by new audiences.
“Probably about 10 years ago, it started to dawn on me. Because it wouldn’t go away. Not to make it about money, but in the Writers Guild, you get residual checks for every movie that you’ve done.
“It starts out nice, and then it just diminishes and diminishes until you’re getting checks for like, US$17 (approx. $22). But A Knight’s Tale never goes down — or it goes down very slowly. So you know, people are still watching it.
“Then, I started to realize when I was junketing other movies, there was always someone who would bring up Knight’s Tale. And no other movie, just that. Let me put it this way: I get way more comments about A Knight’s Tale than I do about L.A. Confidential.”
Will A Knight’s Tale get a long-awaited sequel?
Naturally, the subject of a sequel is often raised by fans.
“Well, we always wanted to do one, but no one at Sony ever really broached it or talked about it,” Helgeland divulged.
“Alan and I had this idea because Wat was talking about buying a ship with his prize money. So we’d open the film and you’d see the group on a boat but pull back and reveal they were galley slaves.
“Then it’s kind of a pirate movie — Ademar kidnaps Jocelyn and takes her to Constantinople and they go to rescue her. But we just couldn’t get any interest.
“Subsequently, Paul pitched me an idea just six months ago which was that William and Jocelyn have a daughter and she wants to get into jousting but obviously can’t take her mask off. Kind of like him at the beginning of the movie. So you follow this woman who’s 18 or 20 years old as she seeks out his friends for help. I mean, I think it would be great.”
Regardless if the story continues, Helgeland has nothing but fond memories of the experience.
“I’ve had plenty of good experiences, but nothing like nothing like that, with medieval towns being built and horses being brought in and jousting. It was unreal. It was unrepeatable.”
By Jenelle Riley for Variety.
For a daily dose of 9Honey, sign up here to receive our top stories straight to your inbox